II. The Imperial Church312-451 CE

c. 320–430 CE · Nile Valley & Desert, Egypt

Desert Fathers and Mothers

Desert Monasticism

Between about 320 and 430 CE, Christians in Egypt began leaving their villages for the desert's edge, in a movement that never really stopped. Persecution had just ended, so they invented a different kind of struggle: fighting the tempting thoughts that rise up from inside a person. This way of life took three real, different shapes. Some lived alone, testing their own choices against an elder's hard-earned wisdom. Others joined communities governed by a rule set down in writing, under an appointed leader. A third group kept mostly to their own cells, then walked in once a week to pray and share a meal together. These two kinds of authority, personal and official, existed side by side and never merged into one. None of this was as cut off from ordinary life as it might sound. Digs at one settlement found a marketplace standing among the monks' own cells. Joining this life meant giving up land, family ties, and a settled home. That cost came gradually, one step at a time, over years, not in a single break.

Listen to the story

Papnoute: an elderly man with a long white beard and a dark cap, in a plain grey robe, hands coiling a length of rope, painted against a warm neutral ground.

Papnoute

The Story

How this tradition took shape

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

Between about 320 and 430, Christians in Egypt left their villages for the edge of the desert. The last empire-wide persecutionempire-wide persecutionThis was the last persecution of Christians across the whole Roman Empire. It began in 303 and ended between 311 and 313.Term had ended between 311 and 313. Until then, dying for the faith had been a way to offer everything. The tradition describes its own struggle in the language of that total confrontation. Now the fight was against demons, and the tempting thoughts they stirred in a person's mind. These Christians saw the leaving itself as the whole work of a Christian life.

AthanasiusAthanasiusBishop of Alexandria, about 296 to 373. He was not a desert monk, and he wrote about Antony from outside.Person, bishop of AlexandriaAlexandriaAn old port city in Egypt's Nile Delta. Alexander the Great founded it in 332 or 331 BCE. In Arabic it is called Iskandariya.Place · pleiades.stoa.org, wrote the Life of AntonyLife of AntonyAthanasius wrote this life of Antony between about 356 and 362. It is the most influential text about the movement. He wrote it from outside the movement.Term between about 356 and 362. The movement's founding portrait rests mostly on that one book, and scholars question how far its details are history. Athanasius says AntonyAntonyAn Egyptian monk, about 251 to 356. Nearly all that is known of him comes from the Life that Athanasius wrote.Person was about eighteen or twenty when his parents died. That was about 270. Soon after, he heard the Gospel read in church as if it had been read for him. He gave the family land to the villagers, and then he gave away the rest.

Antony then left in stages. He lived first near his village, then in an abandoned fort across the river. Last, he went to a mountain in the inner desert, three days' journey out. Athanasius gives a reason only for the last move. Crowds kept finding Antony, and he wanted quiet. By this account he stayed on that mountain for most of the rest of his life.

Not every monk lived alone. About 320, PachomiusPachomiusA monk who lived from about 292 to 346. He started a community of monks at Tabennesi. This is most often dated to about 320.Person gathered monks into a community at TabennesiTabennesiA place where Pachomius gathered his first monks. It is also spelled Tabennisis, and it lies in today's Egypt.Place · pleiades.stoa.org. PalladiusPalladiusA monk in Egypt about 388 to 399 who later became a bishop. He wrote the Lausiac History about 419 to 420.Person, a monk who lived in Egypt, wrote long after Pachomius died. He says an angel gave Pachomius a tablet with a rule on it. Tradition says the community had nine houses for men and two for women when he died in 346. It puts the members, roughly, in the low thousands.

Monks also lived in settlements such as NitriaNitriaA settlement of monks. Palladius says its church was in use only on Saturday and Sunday. Its site lies at Kom el-Barnugi, in today's Egypt.Place · pleiades.stoa.org, KelliaKelliaA settlement of monks' cells. More than 1,500 structures have been identified there. Its site lies at Kousour el-Robbeyat, in today's Egypt.Place · pleiades.stoa.org and ScetisScetisA valley in northern Egypt, now called Wadi el Natrun. Monks of the Coptic church settled there from late antiquity.Place · pleiades.stoa.org. They kept small cells and gathered once a week for worship. Authority worked in two ways. Hermits and the monks of the settlements looked to an elder called abba or ammaabba or ammaAbba is the title for a proven elder who is a man, and amma for a woman. Their word carried teaching weight, though they held no office.Term. This was a person whose wisdom had been proved. Elders held no office. In Pachomius's houses, a written rule and appointed offices governed. Even so, people remembered Pachomius himself as a father-elder. Both kinds of authority stood side by side through these years.

The desert had no fixed course of study. Discernment did that work. Called diakrisisdiakrisisDiscernment, the trained skill of judging rightly between thoughts, practices and counsels. It did the work that a course of study does elsewhere.Term, it was the skill of judging how much discipline a particular person could bear. In the collected sayingscollected sayingsShort words from an elder, each given to one person at one moment of need. Later compilers gathered them after about 430.Term of the elders, one pattern recurs. An eager newcomer asks an elder for an extreme practice, and the elder steers him toward something more moderate.

EvagriusEvagriusA monk who lived about 345 to 399. He settled at Kellia and died there in January 399.Person was a formally educated man. Basil of CaesareaBasil of CaesareaBishop of Caesarea. Palladius says he made Evagrius a reader.Person ordained him a reader, and Gregory of NazianzusGregory of NazianzusA bishop who, Palladius says, ordained Evagrius a deacon.Person made him a deacon. About 385 he settled at Kellia, where he lived for fourteen years. There he wrote a system for the struggle. It sorted the tempting thoughts, the logismoilogismoiThe unwanted thoughts and urges a monk fought. The list of eight kinds is Evagrius's own, and the wider movement did not share it.Term, into eight kinds. It also set out a path from practice to freedom from passion, and then to contemplation. The system belonged to him and his learned circle.

Evagrius died at Kellia in January 399. That year TheophilusTheophilusHe was bishop of Alexandria. His Easter letter of 399 began a quarrel. In 400, monks who followed Origen had to leave Egypt.Person, the bishop of Alexandria, sent an Easter letterEaster letterTheophilus's letter of 399. Cassian says it announced Easter and also took up the belief that God has a human body.Term saying that God has no human body. John CassianJohn CassianA monk who lived about 360 to 435. He wrote the Conferences in Gaul, decades after the events they tell of.Person, a monk who had lived at SceteSceteThis is the same place as Scetis, a valley in northern Egypt. It is now called Wadi el Natrun.Place · pleiades.stoa.org, wrote about it decades later. He reports that almost all the monks of Egypt took the letter badly. They felt it went against Scripture, which they took to give God a human form. Theophilus then reversed course, for reasons scholars dispute. He campaigned against the followers of the teacher OrigenOrigenA Christian teacher in Alexandria, who lived about 185 to 253. His book On First Principles set out the ideas behind the quarrel.Person.

In 400, a council at Alexandriacouncil at AlexandriaA church council held in 400. It condemned Origen and the monks who followed him.Council condemned Origen and the monks who followed him. That year four monk leaders called the Tall BrothersTall BrothersFour brothers who led monasteries in Egypt. The historian Socrates says people called them the Tall Monks, for their height.Person, and others among them, had to leave Egypt. The circle around Evagrius was broken up.

People

The people behind this account

Antony (c. 251–356, at the inner mountain - narrated at Vita SS92-93, written by Athanasius shortly after)

Antony heard one Gospel reading in church and took it as spoken to him directly. He gave away his family's land that same day. Then he withdrew in stages: first to the village's edge, then to an abandoned fort, and finally to a remote inner mountain, where he stayed for the rest of his life.

Pachomius (c. 292–346 - by which point the federation he founded numbered nine houses for men and two for women, membership in the low thousands)

Pachomius founded the desert's first rule-governed community at Tabennesi around 320. By his death in 346, tradition says it had grown into a federation of nine houses for men and two for women. A written rule and named offices governed it, not just one elder's own example.

Sarah

Sarah was one of a small number of women remembered by name in this world's own teaching tradition. Six of her sayings survive. She used to say to her brothers that she was a man, and they were women.

Evagrius (c. 345–January 399, at Kellia - communicating in church at Epiphany, per Palladius ch. XXXVIII)

Evagrius was the most formally educated man the desert produced. Basil of Caesarea ordained him a reader. Gregory of Nazianzus made him a deacon. Then he withdrew to Kellia. There, he organized this world's practical wisdom about tempting thoughts into its most complete scheme. He died in January 399, months before a controversy his own circle could not survive.

Documented stories

Stories worth telling in full

Antony Hears the Gospel Read for Him

c. 270 (a few months after his parents' deaths)

Athanasius tells of Antony, a young man whose parents died not long before. He hears the Gospel read in church and takes it as read for him. He gives the family land to the villagers.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

AthanasiusAthanasiusBishop of Alexandria, about 296 to 373. He was not a desert monk, and he wrote about Antony from outside.Person tells us that AntonyAntonyAn Egyptian monk, about 251 to 356. Nearly all that is known of him comes from the Life that Athanasius wrote.Person was about eighteen or twenty when his parents died. That left him with a little sister and the care of the house.

Less than six months later, he was going into church as he always did. He was thinking of how the apostles had left everything to follow the Saviour. The Gospel was being read. He heard the Lord say to the rich man: "If you want to be perfect, go and sell what you have and give to the poor. Then come and follow me, and you will have treasure in heaven."

Antony went out of the church at once, as though the passage had been read on his account. He gave the villagers his family's land, three hundred Egyptian field measures of good ground. He sold everything else he could move and gave the money to the poor, keeping back a little for his sister.

Later he went into church again and heard the Lord say, "Do not be anxious about tomorrow." He could stay no longer. He went out and gave the rest to the poor as well. He placed his sister with known and faithful virgins to be brought up. From then on he gave himself to a life of discipline outside his house, training himself with patience.

In the next village lived an old man who had been a hermit from his youth. After Antony had seen him, he copied his devotion.

Antony Beaten in the Tombs, and Back Again

about 270 to 286 (the Vita gives no years)

Athanasius has demons beat Antony in a tomb until he cannot speak. An acquaintance carries him to the village church. At midnight Antony comes to himself and asks to be carried back.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

AthanasiusAthanasiusBishop of Alexandria, about 296 to 373. He was not a desert monk, and he wrote about Antony from outside.Person writes that AntonyAntonyAn Egyptian monk, about 251 to 356. Nearly all that is known of him comes from the Life that Athanasius wrote.Person went to the tombs, which lay some distance from the village. He asked an acquaintance to bring him bread at long intervals. Then he entered a tomb, and the man shut the door on him.

One night, he says, the enemy came with a crowd of demons and beat him until he lay speechless. Next day the acquaintance found him lying as though dead and carried him to the village church. Kinsfolk and villagers sat around him as around a corpse.

About midnight Antony came to himself. Everyone else was asleep, so he motioned to the acquaintance and asked to be carried back to the tombs.

Alone again, he lay unable to stand. That night the demons seemed to break through the walls in the likeness of lions, bears, leopards, serpents and wolves. Antony mocked them: "If you had any real power, it would have been enough for just one of you to come. But the Lord has made you weak. So you try to frighten me with your numbers."

Then the roof seemed to open, and a ray of light came down. The demons vanished and the pain stopped. Antony asked, "Where were you? Why did you not appear at the start, to end my pain?" A voice answered: "Antony, I was here, but I waited to see your fight. You have endured and have not given way. So I will always help you, and I will make your name known everywhere."

Antony Moves Further Out

about 270 to 313 (the Vita gives no years)

Antony leaves the world in stages. He lives near his village, then in an abandoned fort across the river, then on a mountain in the inner desert. Athanasius gives a reason only for the last move, that crowds beset him and he could not be still.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

AntonyAntonyAn Egyptian monk, about 251 to 356. Nearly all that is known of him comes from the Life that Athanasius wrote.Person left the world in stages. First he lived near his own village, as all did who wished to train in those days. He had seen an old hermit in the next village and copied his devotion.

Later he found a fort on the far side of the river. It had stood empty so long that it was full of creeping things. Antony crossed over and lived there, and the creatures, AthanasiusAthanasiusBishop of Alexandria, about 296 to 373. He was not a desert monk, and he wrote about Antony from outside.Person wrote, fled at once as if someone were chasing them. He built up the entrance completely and stored six months of loaves. He found water inside. He stayed alone, never going out and never looking at anyone who came, and loaves were let down to him from above twice a year.

Friends who came were not let in. They often spent days and nights outside, and they heard what sounded like crowds clamouring within.

Nearly twenty years later he came out, and in time, Athanasius says, he was beset by many people and could not be still. Then a voice came to him from above and told him that, if he truly wanted quiet, he should go into the inner desert. He journeyed three days and three nights with Saracens, desert nomads, who were going that way. He came to a very lofty mountain, with a clear spring at its foot, a plain, and a few uncared-for palm trees. He recognised the place as his own home and stayed.

Pachomius, the Angel and the Brass Tablet

about 318 to 346 (the founding is most often placed about 320, and Pachomius died in 346)

Palladius says an angel appears to Pachomius in his cave and sends him to gather the young monks. The angel gives him a brass tablet with a rule written on it.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

PalladiusPalladiusA monk in Egypt about 388 to 399 who later became a bishop. He wrote the Lausiac History about 419 to 420.Person tells of a man named PachomiusPachomiusA monk who lived from about 292 to 346. He started a community of monks at Tabennesi. This is most often dated to about 320.Person, who lived at Tabennisi in the Thebaid. He says Pachomius was counted worthy of prophecies and of angelic visions. Palladius says an angel appeared to him as he sat in his cave. The angel told him he had ordered his own life well, so it was pointless to stay in the cave any longer. He was to go out, gather all the young monks, and live with them.

The angel gave him a brass tablet with a rule written on it. Each man was to eat and drink according to his strength, and his work was to match that strength. Pachomius objected that the prayers it set were few. The angel answered that he had given the rule so that even the little ones would keep it. The perfect, he said, need no rule, because alone in their cells they have given their whole lives to the contemplation of God.

In his own day, Palladius says, the monasteries that kept this rule held some seven thousand men. The first and great monastery was the one where Pachomius himself had lived, and he gives it thirteen hundred members.

The Rule That Opens With an Angel

about 318 to 346 (the years of Pachomius's community)

The Ethiopic text of the Pachomian rule opens with a story about where it came from. An angel of the Lord hands Pachomius an iron tablet with the rule written on it. Pachomius answers that the prayers are few.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

The Ethiopic rule of PachomiusPachomiusA monk who lived from about 292 to 346. He started a community of monks at Tabennesi. This is most often dated to about 320.Person begins by saying where it came from. Its first words are: "In the name of the holy Trinity. This is the rule which the angel of the Lord gave to Abba Pachomius as a command."

Then the text tells a story. In a place called Tabennesis, in the province of Thebes, there was a man named Pachomius, one of those who lived a clean life. Knowledge was given to him, and also the sight of angels. As he sat in his cave, the angel of the Lord appeared to him. The angel said that Pachomius had become perfect in his own life, and that living on in the cave was now needless. He should go out, gather the less perfect young men, and live with them. As the angel gave him a rule, so he should teach them.

Then the angel handed him a tablet of iron, with the rule written on it. At the end of the rule's commands, Pachomius answered the angel: "These prayers are few." The angel said he had commanded it so that the weak also might keep the rule without grieving themselves. The perfect do not desire a rule for themselves. These things, he said, he had ordained for those who have no advisers.

Arsenius Asks How to Live

undated, within about 320 to 430

One saying has Arsenius pray in the palace to be shown how to live, and a voice tells him to flee from men. A second saying has him pray the same prayer as a monk. This time the voice adds silence and a life of silent contemplation.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

Our sayings tell of Abba ArseniusArseniusA monk of the Syriac sayings. Two of them tell of a voice that showed him how to live. The first places him in a palace.Person when he was in the palace. He prayed to God, "Lord, show me how to live." A voice came to him and said, "Arsenius, flee from men, and you will live."

A second saying tells of the time when he was living the ascetic life in the monastery. He prayed the same prayer, and again he heard a voice. It said, "Arsenius, flee. Keep silence. Live a life of silent contemplation. These are the basic causes that keep a person from sinning."

Moses Comes to Judge With a Leaking Basket

undated, within about 320 to 430 (told as tradition)

A congregation at Scete meets to judge a brother who has done wrong. Abba Moses comes at last, carrying a basket of sand with a hole in it. He says the sand is his own sins running out behind him, and the congregation sets the brother free.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

Our sayings tell of a brother at SceteSceteThis is the same place as Scetis, a valley in northern Egypt. It is now called Wadi el Natrun.Place · pleiades.stoa.org, the camp of the monks, who committed an offence. A congregation met on the matter. They sent for Abba MosesAbba MosesAn elder at Scete in the Syriac sayings. Abba means father, a title of respect for an elder.Person, but he refused to come. Then they sent the priest of the church to him, saying, "Come. All the people are waiting for you." Moses got up and came.

He took a basket with a hole in it, filled it with sand, and carried it on his shoulders. Those who went out to meet him asked, "What does this mean, father?" He said the sand was "my sins, running down behind me. I cannot see them." And today, he said, he had come to judge faults that were not his own.

When they heard this, they set the brother free and said nothing more to him.

Amma Sarah Speaks to Her Brothers

undated, within about 320 to 430

A saying has Amma Sarah tell her brothers that she is a man and they are women. The saying accepts the era's view that courage is manly and weakness womanly. She claims the first for herself.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

Amma SarahAmma SarahOne of a few women remembered by name in the desert tradition. The Syriac collection keeps six sayings under her name.Person is one of a few women our teaching tradition remembers by name. The Syriac collection keeps six sayings under her name. In our speech, steadfast courage was called manly, and weakness womanly. Amma Sarah used to say to her brothers, "It is I who am a man, and you who are women."

Buried Where Only Two Men Knew

356 (Antony's death)

Antony will not die among the monks who beg him to stay. He orders the two men who serve him to bury him in secret. Athanasius writes that no one but those two knows where he lies.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

AthanasiusAthanasiusBishop of Alexandria, about 296 to 373. He was not a desert monk, and he wrote about Antony from outside.Person writes that AntonyAntonyAn Egyptian monk, about 251 to 356. Nearly all that is known of him comes from the Life that Athanasius wrote.Person visited the monks of the outer mountain and told them it was his last visit. He said he would be surprised if they met again in this life, and that he was near a hundred and five years old.

The monks begged him to stay and die among them. He would not, and above all for one reason. The Egyptians wrapped the bodies of good men in linen and kept them on couches in their houses. Antony had often urged the bishops to command the people against this, and he had taught that it was neither lawful nor holy.

He went back to the inner mountain, where he was used to living, and a few months later he fell sick. Two men had stayed with him there for fifteen years, serving him because of his age. He called them and told them to let no one take his body into Egypt. "Bury my body and hide it underground yourselves," he said. "Keep my words, so that no one may know the place but you alone."

He told them to divide his garments. One sheepskin and the garment he lay on were for the bishop Athanasius. The other sheepskin was for the bishop Serapion, and the two men were to keep the hair garment. Then he said farewell, and died.

They buried him as he had commanded. Athanasius writes that to this day no one knows where he lies, except those two.

They Have Taken My God Away From Me

399 (soon after the bishop's Easter letter reached Scete)

Cassian tells of Sarapion, an old monk at Scete who holds that God has a human form. A learned visiting deacon persuades him otherwise. As the brothers rise to pray, Sarapion weeps and cries out that they have taken his God away from him.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

Cassian tells of an old monk named SarapionSarapionAn old monk at Scete who had kept a strict life for a long time.Person, who lived at SceteSceteThis is the same place as Scetis, a valley in northern Egypt. It is now called Wadi el Natrun.Place · pleiades.stoa.org. Sarapion had kept a strict life there for a long time.

Then letters came from TheophilusTheophilusHe was bishop of Alexandria. His Easter letter of 399 began a quarrel. In 400, monks who followed Origen had to leave Egypt.Person, the bishop of AlexandriaAlexandriaAn old port city in Egypt's Nile Delta. Alexander the Great founded it in 332 or 331 BCE. In Arabic it is called Iskandariya.Place · pleiades.stoa.org, refuting the belief that God has a human form. Almost all the monks of Egypt took them with great bitterness. At Scete, Cassian says, only Paphnutius, the presbyter of his own congregation, would allow the letter to be read.

Sarapion was one of those who held that belief. Paphnutius urged him many times, but the bishop's teaching seemed new to him, never handed down by his predecessors. Then a learned deacon named Photinus arrived from Cappadocia. Paphnutius asked him a question before all the brothers. How did the churches of the East read the words in Genesis, "Let us make man after our image and likeness"? Photinus answered that they took the words spiritually, not by the bare letters, and that God's glory could not be held in a human shape. At last the old man was shaken and agreed.

Cassian says they were all delighted. But as they rose to pray together, Sarapion felt the picture of God he used to set before himself in prayer leave his heart. He burst into bitter tears, threw himself on the ground, and cried out with deep groans: "Alas! I am a wretched man! They have taken my God away from me. Now I have no one to hold on to. I do not know whom to worship, or whom to address."

Legacy

What came after

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

This world's own eight named categories of tempting thought did not stay here. Passed west through Cassian's Conferences and narrowed two centuries later by Gregory the Great, they became the seven deadly sins of later Western moral teaching.

One popular link does not actually hold. This world's own word for the stillness it sought, hesychia, is often assumed to be the same practice as the later Byzantine Hesychast tradition and its Jesus Prayer technique. That systematized method belongs to a separate, later tradition and is not part of this one's own record.

In its own words

A few terms and lines worth knowing

Mother Sarah used to say to her brothers: 'It is I who am a man, and you who are women.'

Sarah

Now it is necessary for us to also remember the chosen and mighty women. God gave them, as he also gave men, an equal measure of strength of will. This was so that they would have no cause to be feeble in the labor of ascetic excellence.

Palladius, in the Syriac recension of the Paradise

Alas! I am a wretched man! They have taken my God away from me. Now I have no one to hold on to. I do not know whom to worship, or whom to address.

Abbot Sarapion of Scete, as Cassian records him - a different named elder from the Abbot Serapion of Conference V (the eight-principal-faults teaching); the surviving text marks the two with different spellings

There are eight main faults that attack people. First is gastrimargia, which means gluttony. Second is fornication. Third is philargyria, that is, avarice, or the love of money. Fourth is anger. Fifth is dejection. Sixth is acedia, that is, listlessness, or low spirits. Seventh is cenodoxia, that is, boasting, or vain glory. Eighth is pride.

Abbot Serapion of Scetis, as Cassian records him
anachoresis
Withdrawal: leaving settled life for the desert's edge as the whole work of formation. It was far more than a change of address.
apophthegma
The saying: a short word from an elder, given to one person for one moment of need. It was our main way of teaching.
diakrisis
Discernment: the skill of judging rightly between thoughts, practices, and counsels. It set the measure for all our other practices.
logismoi
The thoughts: unwanted, intruding thoughts and urges. We treated them as the main battlefield of the ascetic life.
hesychia
Stillness: quiet of body and mind, sought as both the condition and the fruit of the ascetic life.

The Table

Come and join us at the Table

Begin a conversation with Papnoute

Because of cost, we're asking each participant to keep to about five conversations for now — we can't enforce this yet, only ask.

The other traditions →