I. The Early Church70-312 CE

c. 150–400 CE · Alexandria, Egypt

Alexandrian Christianity

Alexandrian Catechetical Tradition

In Alexandria, from about 150 to 400 CE, teachers led seekers through a shared reading of Scripture. They read for a deeper meaning beneath the surface, one that opened onto the Logos himself. This teaching reached the literate few. Ordinary believers met the same faith another way — through baptism, the shared meal, and the yearly round of fasts and feasts. Some call this one continuous school, led by one teacher after another. Others say it was simply a series of private teachers, grouped together only in hindsight. When plague struck the city, Bishop Dionysius wrote to his own church, praising his people for nursing the sick and burying the dead. Others, he wrote, fled the city instead. Persecution could reach the school's own teachers, not only the wider community. Origen himself was imprisoned and tortured under the emperor Decius, and he died a few years later. It had already touched his boyhood, too. His father was martyred in an earlier persecution, when Origen was still just a boy.

Listen to the story

Theon: an older man with close-cropped grey hair in a plain white tunic, pointing to a line of Greek text on a papyrus scroll he holds, painted against a warm neutral ground.

Theon

The Story

How this tradition took shape

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

From about 150 to 400 CE, Christians in AlexandriaAlexandriaA port city in Egypt's Nile Delta, founded by Alexander the Great in 332 or 331 BCE. Its modern name is Iskandariya.Place · pleiades.stoa.org and across Egypt passed on one faith in two ways. Through long study together, teachers formed the few who could read. Baptism, the EucharistEucharistThe thanksgiving meal of bread and cup at the center of worship. Members shared it whether or not they could read.Term and the yearly round of fasts and feasts reached everyone else.

Both ways answered to one center, the LogosLogosGreek for the Word. It names God's own reason and speech, through whom all things were made and who became flesh in Jesus.Term. He is God's Word, through whom all things were made, and who became flesh. Through him, Scripture, learning, worship and the remaking of a person became one movement toward one God.

OrigenOrigenOrigen lived from about 185 to about 253. He taught in Alexandria until he broke with his bishop. Then he taught in Caesarea.Person taught that Scripture, like a person, has body, soul and spirit. It has a plain sense and deeper senses that point to Christ and the soul. This way of reading is called allegoriaallegoriaReading Scripture at more than one level. There is a plain sense, and deeper senses about Christ and the soul. Egyptian Christians disagreed about it.Term. But the bishop NeposNeposAn Egyptian bishop who wrote a book against the allegorists. He read the promises in Scripture as a thousand-year kingdom on earth.Person wrote a book against it, and village churches in the Arsinoite districtArsinoite districtThe capital here was probably Arsinoe. It stood at Medinet el-Fayum, in Egypt today. The villages that followed Nepos lay here.Place · pleiades.stoa.org followed his book. After Nepos died, Bishop DionysiusDionysiusBishop of Alexandria from about 248 to 264. Before that he led the teaching. He led the church through persecution and plague.Person answered them with three days of open argument, and the leader of the other side was persuaded.

Alexandria had a long tradition of Christian teachers and their pupils. The first name kept is PantaenusPantaenusThe first teacher in this tradition whose name was kept. He taught about 180 to 200.Person, a Stoic philosopher who became a Christian. ClementClementClement was born about 150 and died about 215. He taught in the city from about 180. He left when persecution came under Severus.Person taught in the city from about 180. He praised his last teacher as the true bee. That teacher gathered from the flowers of the prophets and apostles, and left a deathless knowledge in his hearers' souls. Clement gives no name, and EusebiusEusebiusEusebius of Caesarea, about 260 to 339. His Church History is the main source here. He is more reliable when he quotes documents.Person says it was Pantaenus. Origen came after Clement, and Eusebius says he led the teaching of those preparing for baptism from his eighteenth year. Scholars disagree on whether a formal school stood behind these names before Origen's time.

A teacher and a bishop each held real authority, and the two never became one. The teacher's standing came from the wisdom people saw in him. The bishop held an office handed down. In the early 230s, Eusebius tells us, bishops in Palestine ordained Origen, the city's greatest teacher. His own bishop, DemetriusDemetriusHe was bishop of Alexandria for forty-three years, until about 232.Person, had not agreed. He condemned the ordination and the teacher with it. Origen left for CaesareaCaesareaA city on the coast of Roman Palestine. Its site, Qesaria, is in today's Israel. Origen lived and taught here.Place · pleiades.stoa.org and never taught in the city again.

Persecution came more than once. Origen's father was beheaded about 202. Origen himself was jailed and tortured under DeciusDeciusThe persecution of 249 to 251 bears his name. Origen was jailed and tortured in it.Person. The church held two pictures of a life fully formed. One was the martyr's witness unto death. The other was the soul's long climb toward God. About 260, plague struck Alexandria. Bishop Dionysius wrote that most of his people did not run. They nursed the sick, and many caught the sickness and died.

Then the danger came from inside, as brothers argued over the very confession of the Word. AriusAriusHe taught that the Son was the highest creature. The dispute over his teaching ran from about 318 to 381.Person taught that the Son was the highest creature and not fully God. In 325 the council at NicaeaCouncil of NicaeaA meeting of bishops in 325. It answered the teaching of Arius with the word homoousios.Council answered with the word homoousioshomoousiosGreek for of one substance. The council at Nicaea used it to say the Son is fully God. Critics said it is not in Scripture.Term, meaning of one substance with the Father. AthanasiusAthanasiusBorn about 296, he was bishop of Alexandria from 328 to 373. He was exiled five times.Person, bishop from 328 to 373, defended it through five exiles. Later he wrote that the bishops had added nothing new. They had fenced what the churches had received. He also wrote that the Word became human so that people could share God's own life.

After NicaeaNicaeaA Greek city of northwestern Anatolia, now İznik in Turkey. The council of 325 met here.Place · pleiades.stoa.org, the bishop of Alexandria became the guard of the creed across Egypt. His tools were letters, councils and exile. Among those who could read, the long bond between teacher and student was no longer the main way faith was formed.

Later tradition ends the line of teachers with DidymusDidymusDidymus the Blind, about 309 or 313 to about 398. Later tradition says he headed the school. Palladius, Jerome and Socrates do not say so.Person and says he headed the school in its last years. Didymus was blind from the age of four, too young to have learned letters. He died about 398, at eighty-five.

The Nicene creedNicene creedThe statement of faith from the council at Nicaea in 325. It says the Son is of one substance with the Father.Term and the hope of sharing God's life reached Eastern Christianity. So did the habit of reading Scripture with Christ at its center. Origen's work was carried forward too, and people loved it and argued over it.

People

The people behind this account

Origen (c. 185–c. 253/4, Tyre, after imprisonment and torture under Decius: 'At this time Origen died, being sixty-nine years of age')

Origen was this world's greatest and most contested teacher. He took over the school as a very young man, after his own father was martyred. As a youth he acted on a hard verse from Matthew far too literally, and his bishop, Demetrius, first admired him for it, then later used the same act against him. Origen wrote commentaries across almost all of Scripture, argued at length with pagan critics, and was finally imprisoned and tortured under the emperor Decius. He died of it a few years later.

Athanasius (c. 296-298–373)

Athanasius was bishop of Alexandria for forty-six years, through five separate exiles. He defended one confession under real threat: the Son is truly God, of one substance with the Father. Arius had called the Son merely the highest creature. Near the end of this world's story, Athanasius put the hope of that confession into one line: God became human so that humans could share God's own life. He also wrote the best-known portrait of Antony, the desert's founding figure, holding him up as this city's own picture of a formed life.

Dionysius (c. 264/5)

Dionysius studied under Origen before becoming bishop himself. He led the church through two of this world's hardest tests: the Decian persecution and a citywide plague. He wrote that his own people nursed the dying without fear, while others in the city fled. When whole villages in the Egyptian countryside took up a teaching he thought was wrong, he did not condemn them from a distance. He traveled out, sat with them for three days, and won them back through patient argument.

Didymus (c. 309-313–c. 398)

Didymus was blind from the age of four, too young to have ever read a written word himself. He held the whole of Scripture in memory, and taught from it for decades. Visitors came from far away to hear him. Later tradition remembers him as the last head of this world's teaching line, closing out its final generation.

Documented stories

Stories worth telling in full

The Apostle John and the Young Robber

Told by Clement, between about 180 and 215

Clement passes on a tradition about the apostle John, who rides out to bring back a young man turned robber chief. Clement calls it a true account handed down.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

In a city not far from EphesusEphesusA great city of Ionia. Its ruins lie by Selçuk, in today's Turkey. Clement's story of John is set in a city near it.Place · pleiades.stoa.org, the aged apostle John once left a promising young man in the bishop's care. ClementClementClement was born about 150 and died about 215. He taught in the city from about 180. He left when persecution came under Severus.Person, one of our teachers, passed this on as a true account, handed down and kept in memory.

The bishop taught the young man and baptized him. Then he relaxed his watch. The young man fell in with idle companions, and then with worse ones. At last he ran to the hills and became chief of a band of robbers.

Years later John came back and asked the bishop to return what he had left in his keeping. The bishop wept. The young man was dead to God, he said, a robber on the mountain. The old apostle tore his clothes, called for a horse and rode out to the mountain himself.

When the young man saw him, he fled. John forgot his age and rode after him. He begged his child not to run from his own father, old and unarmed. There was still hope of life for him, John said, and he would answer for him to Christ.

The young man stopped, threw down his weapons and wept. John led him back, prayed with him and fasted beside him in the struggle. He did not leave until he had restored him to the church.

A Father in Prison and a Son Kept Home

About 202, under the emperor Severus

Origen's father, Leonides, is arrested and held for beheading. His sixteen-year-old son wants to die beside him, and the boy's mother hides his clothes to keep him home.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

About the year 202, under the emperor SeverusSeverusA Roman emperor. In his reign, about 202, the hunt for Christians struck Alexandria, and Origen's father was put to death.Person, persecution struck AlexandriaAlexandriaA port city in Egypt's Nile Delta, founded by Alexander the Great in 332 or 331 BCE. Its modern name is Iskandariya.Place · pleiades.stoa.org. Leonides was arrested and held for beheading. His son OrigenOrigenOrigen lived from about 185 to about 253. He taught in Alexandria until he broke with his bishop. Then he taught in Caesarea.Person was sixteen. EusebiusEusebiusEusebius of Caesarea, about 260 to 339. His Church History is the main source here. He is more reliable when he quotes documents.Person tells what happened next in that house. He wrote a century later, from our church's memory, from Origen's own letters and from reports about him.

The boy burned to give himself up and die beside his father. His mother begged him to spare her, but he would not listen. So she hid all his clothes, and shame kept him at home.

Origen did the one thing left to him. He wrote to his father in prison. One line of that letter survives, "Take heed not to change your mind on our account."

Leonides did not change his mind. He was beheaded, and the family's property was seized. Not yet seventeen, Origen was left the eldest of seven children, and his mother was a widow.

Potamiaena, as the Church Remembered Her

Under the emperor Severus, between 203 and 211

Eusebius records a tradition about Potamiaena, a young woman put to death under Severus. It says she stood fast, and that the soldier who led her out later died a Christian.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

When EusebiusEusebiusEusebius of Caesarea, about 260 to 339. His Church History is the main source here. He is more reliable when he quotes documents.Person wrote, PotamiaenaPotamiaenaA young woman put to death under Severus. Her story comes to us as a tradition that devotion has shaped.Person was still famous among the people of the country for all she had endured. Her story reached him already shaped by devotion.

She was a young woman put to death under the emperor SeverusSeverusA Roman emperor. In his reign, about 202, the hunt for Christians struck Alexandria, and Origen's father was put to death.Person, and her mother Marcella died with her. She was threatened with what ancient cruelty kept for women, and she stood fast. The tradition says the judge sentenced her to die by burning pitch, poured slowly.

A soldier named BasilidesBasilidesThe soldier who led Potamiaena to her death. Eusebius counts him among Origen's disciples who died for the faith.Person led her out. The tradition says he held back the crowd's abuse with such gentleness that she told him to take courage. She promised, it says, to ask her Lord for him when she was gone.

Not long after, his fellow soldiers asked Basilides to swear an oath. He refused, because he was a Christian. At first they thought he was joking, but he was not. The tradition says he told them the reason. Potamiaena had come to him in the night and set a crown on his head.

Our church baptized him in prison. Then he was beheaded.

A Hard Verse and a Young Teacher, as Eusebius Tells It

Origen's early teaching years; used against him in 231 or 232

Eusebius reports that young Origen took a hard verse in Matthew at its word. His bishop first praised him and later denounced him, and some have doubted the act happened.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

OrigenOrigenOrigen lived from about 185 to about 253. He taught in Alexandria until he broke with his bishop. Then he taught in Caesarea.Person was still young, and teaching the faith in AlexandriaAlexandriaA port city in Egypt's Nile Delta, founded by Alexander the Great in 332 or 331 BCE. Its modern name is Iskandariya.Place · pleiades.stoa.org. He taught men and women together, day and night.

EusebiusEusebiusEusebius of Caesarea, about 260 to 339. His Church History is the main source here. He is more reliable when he quotes documents.Person alone tells what Origen did then, and no account from Origen himself describes it. Eusebius says Origen wanted no one to accuse him of wrong, so he took a hard verse from Matthew in the most literal sense. It speaks of those who "have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven's sake." By this account he acted on it himself, and tried to keep it secret, but he could not. Eusebius calls the act immature, and in the same breath a proof of unusual faith.

When his bishop, DemetriusDemetriusHe was bishop of Alexandria for forty-three years, until about 232.Person, learned of it, he admired the young man's daring and faith, and urged him to keep teaching. Later, once Origen had grown famous beyond Alexandria, the same Demetrius turned that youthful act against him. He wrote to bishops everywhere calling it foolish. He also attacked Origen's ordination by the bishops of CaesareaCaesareaA city on the coast of Roman Palestine. Its site, Qesaria, is in today's Israel. Origen lived and taught here.Place · pleiades.stoa.org and Jerusalem.

Some have doubted that it happened at all, and thought the report grew from Origen's own figures of speech. Others see no reason to doubt it.

Origen himself later judged the verse differently. He wrote against reading it so literally.

The Break Between Origen and His Bishop

Between 231 and 234

Origen is ordained away from home, and his own bishop has not agreed to it. The bishop condemns it, and Origen never teaches in his city again.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

For years the teacher and the bishop held together. DemetriusDemetriusHe was bishop of Alexandria for forty-three years, until about 232.Person governed our church and OrigenOrigenOrigen lived from about 185 to about 253. He taught in Alexandria until he broke with his bishop. Then he taught in Caesarea.Person taught, and the fame of the school filled the city.

Nearly all we know of what came next comes from EusebiusEusebiusEusebius of Caesarea, about 260 to 339. His Church History is the main source here. He is more reliable when he quotes documents.Person. He admired Origen, and he was hostile to the memory of Demetrius.

The break came over authority. On a journey through Palestine, Origen was ordained a presbyterpresbyterAn office in the church. Clement taught that a good life came first, and the office came after it.Term by the bishops there. His own bishop had not agreed to it. Demetrius condemned the ordination, and the teacher with it.

Around his forty-sixth year, Origen left AlexandriaAlexandriaA port city in Egypt's Nile Delta, founded by Alexander the Great in 332 or 331 BCE. Its modern name is Iskandariya.Place · pleiades.stoa.org for CaesareaCaesareaA city on the coast of Roman Palestine. Its site, Qesaria, is in today's Israel. Origen lived and taught here.Place · pleiades.stoa.org. He never taught in the city again.

The church kept both memories, the office that had to be honored and the teacher. What each man said, and with what heart, we cannot hear. The synods' rulings from the break are lost.

A Student's Farewell to Origen

About 233 to 238

At Caesarea, a student named Gregory thanks Origen in a farewell speech. He says the teaching came in stages, and that it kindled his love for the Word.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

OrigenOrigenOrigen lived from about 185 to about 253. He taught in Alexandria until he broke with his bishop. Then he taught in Caesarea.Person did not begin with doctrines, GregoryGregory of NeocaesareaAbout 213 to about 270. He studied with Origen at Caesarea from about 233 to 238. People question the date and author of his farewell speech.Person says. He began like a farmer testing soil. He questioned young Gregory and dug into his mind to see what it did under pressure.

Gregory had come from Neo-CaesareaNeo-CaesareaGregory's home city, in Pontus. Its site is Niksar, in today's Turkey.Place · pleiades.stoa.org, in Pontus, to study law. At CaesareaCaesareaA city on the coast of Roman Palestine. Its site, Qesaria, is in today's Israel. Origen lived and taught here.Place · pleiades.stoa.org he met Origen, and he stayed some five years. He tells how he was taught in a farewell speech of praise, though who gave it, and when, is not settled.

Logic came first, to make thinking honest. Next came the natural world, geometry and the stars, until the students' sense of wonder was trained. Then came ethics, formed as habits, with the teacher's own life teaching as well. Only then came theology. They read everything the philosophers and poets had said of God, with Scripture at the center.

Under all of it, Gregory says, something else was happening. Love was kindled in his inmost soul, like a spark falling there. It was love for the holy Word, and for this man who was the Word's friend. Gregory gave up the law. When at last he had to leave, he called it being driven out of paradise.

Three Days of Argument in the Villages

In the years Dionysius was bishop, about 248 to 264

In the Arsinoite district, villages follow the book of their late bishop Nepos. Dionysius comes out and sits with them for three days, going through it argument by argument.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

The village churches near Arsinoe loved a bishop named NeposNeposAn Egyptian bishop who wrote a book against the allegorists. He read the promises in Scripture as a thousand-year kingdom on earth.Person. He had written a book against the allegorists. The promises in Scripture, he said, meant a thousand-year kingdom of plenty on this earth, plainly read. Nepos had died, and his book now ruled whole congregations. That book is lost. We know it only from the bishop who answered it.

Our bishop DionysiusDionysiusBishop of Alexandria from about 248 to 264. Before that he led the teaching. He led the church through persecution and plague.Person went out to the villages. He told the story himself, in his book On the Promises, and EusebiusEusebiusEusebius of Caesarea, about 260 to 339. His Church History is the main source here. He is more reliable when he quotes documents.Person later quoted it. He called together the elders and the teachers, and any of the people who wished to come. For three days, from morning to evening, he sat with them and examined the book, argument by argument.

He wrote afterward that he loved Nepos for his faith, his hard work in the Scriptures and his psalms. Even so, he wrote, "the truth should be loved and honored most of all." He rejoiced in the constancy and sincerity of the believers, and in their willingness to reconsider as they weighed the arguments together.

At the end, Coracion, the leader of the other side, was persuaded. He said so in front of everyone. Some of the other believers, the account says, were glad at the spirit of agreement all had shown.

Nursing the Sick in the Plague

About 260, while Dionysius was bishop

Bishop Dionysius writes to the churches that most of his people did not run from the plague. They visited the sick and tended them, and many caught the sickness and died.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

A great sickness came to AlexandriaAlexandriaA port city in Egypt's Nile Delta, founded by Alexander the Great in 332 or 331 BCE. Its modern name is Iskandariya.Place · pleiades.stoa.org about the year 260, and every house had its dead. Our bishop DionysiusDionysiusBishop of Alexandria from about 248 to 264. Before that he led the teaching. He led the church through persecution and plague.Person wrote to the churches at festival time, while the plague still raged.

Most of the brothers and sisters did not run, he wrote. They visited the sick without fear, tended them day after day and served them in Christ.

Many caught the sickness from those they nursed, and they died of it. He wrote that they died most joyfully, as if drawing their neighbors' pain onto themselves. Our church buried its dead with open hands.

In the same letter, he said the pagans thrust away their own sick at the first sign of illness, and fled even from their dearest.

The Blind Teacher Palladius Met

Between 380 and 398

Palladius visits Didymus four times over ten years. The old teacher has been blind since the age of four, too young to have learned letters.

Read the full account

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

DidymusDidymusDidymus the Blind, about 309 or 313 to about 398. Later tradition says he headed the school. Palladius, Jerome and Socrates do not say so.Person lost his sight at four, he told PalladiusPalladiusPalladius of Galatia, about 363 to about 430. He wrote the Lausiac History in 419 and 420. It tells of his visits to Didymus.Person, too young ever to have learned to read. Palladius met him four times over ten years and wrote down what he saw.

By then Didymus was old. What others took in with their eyes, he had taken in through his ears and held on to. He interpreted Scripture word by word. Palladius calls him the blind author. Jerome, who studied with him briefly, says, writing in 392 or 393, that he had already passed his eighty-third year.

Later tradition called him the seer, a name set against his blindness. Most of the books he wrote are lost to us, and only fragments were recovered, centuries later.

He died at the age of eighty-five.

Legacy

What came after

Synthesized voice — not a recording.

Two things carried past this world's own horizon, in different ways. The first was a settled inheritance. This world passed on the Nicene confession, the hope of sharing God's own life, and Scripture read for a deeper meaning beneath its surface. Basil of Caesarea and Gregory of Nazianzus, teachers of a later generation, gathered an anthology of Origen's own writing while this world's own record was still open. The second thing was a live argument, not a settled one. Origen's boldest ideas kept being read, loved, and contested by turns. Interested translators carried them on both sides. The argument finally broke into open controversy right at this world's own edge.

In its own words

A few terms and lines worth knowing

Question I. A boy of seven, or a man, who is a catechumen may be present at the offering and eat of it in ignorance. What should be done? Answer. Let him be illuminated, that is, baptized, for he is called by God. ... Question VIII. Should a woman who has just given birth keep the Paschal fast? Answer. No. ... Question X. Is a sick man required to keep the Paschal fast? Answer. No. Question XI. A clergyman is called to celebrate a marriage, and he has heard that it is incestuous. Should he comply and perform the offering? Answer. No; he must not share in other men's sins.

Timothy, bishop of Alexandria (d. 385), answering questions put to him
Logos
The Word: God's own reason and speech, through whom all things were made, and who became flesh in Jesus.
allegoria (the spiritual sense)
Reading Scripture at more than one level: the plain sense, and deeper senses about Christ and the soul.
theosis
Becoming like God: sharing in God's own life, as far as a creature can. Athanasius wrote that the Word became man that we might be made God.
katechesis
The teaching given to people preparing for baptism: step by step, over a long time.
paideia
God's way of raising souls: he teaches through Scripture, through teachers, and even through hardship.

The Table

Come and join us at the Table

Begin a conversation with Theon

Because of cost, we're asking each participant to keep to about five conversations for now — we can't enforce this yet, only ask.

The other traditions →